Bake Me a Wish Reviews

Published on October 13, 2021
Last modified on October 14, 2021

For this Bake Me A Wish reviews we were given a sample and this post contains affiliate links.  If you make a purchase we may be compensated.  All opinions are our own.

gold gift box tower with purple ribbon-bake me a wish reviews-mealfinds

By Alison Chew

Bake Me a Wish Reviews

Bake Me A Wish delivers freshly baked gourmet bakery gifts including cakes for birthdays, holidays, and special occasions directly to your door with overnight nationwide delivery.

With delicious baked goods, customization options, personalized greeting cards, elegant packaging, and overnight delivery Bake Me A Wish has become the premier destination for birthday cake delivery as well as seasonal cakes and pie gifts, gift baskets, and more.

SHOP NOW >>

What We Like

  • Beautiful packaging
  • Personalization options
  • Can select a delivery date
  • 100% guarantee for fresh delivery

What We Don’t Like

  • Additional shipping fee
  • Limited specialty products such as Halal, Vegan, Dairy-Free, Egg Free, Sugar-Free, or Completely Nut Free

How much is a Bake Me A Wish gift?

rainbow birthday cake-bake me a wish-mealfinds

The cost of a Bake Me A Wish gift is between $32 and $160 depending on the type of bakery fresh gift you order.

  • Birthday Cake Delivery: $45 – $55
  • Cupcake Gifts: $45 – $52
  • Cheesecake Gifts: $49 – $55
  • Seasonal Cakes, Pies, and Cupcakes: $38 – $65
  • Gift Towers: $59 – $160
  • Gift Baskets: $32 – $115
  • SHOP NOW >>

 

Bake Me A Wish ships all gifts anywhere within the United States via shipping partner UPS.  They are also able to ship gifts to US Military personnel across the seas stationed at US military bases (FPO, APO, APE, DPO).

Shipping and handling fees start at $19.99 and gifts can be sent overnight or 2-day.

Bake Me a Wish Reviews

gold boxes stacked with purple ribbon-bake me a wish reviews-mealfinds

Bake Me A Wish has a wide assortment of cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, cookies, brownies, and pies as well as gift towers and gift baskets packed with bakery fresh treats.

And while they are best known for their personalized freshly made Birthday Cake delivery in best-selling flavors like Chocolate Mousse, Red Velvet, Vanilla Bean, Tiramisu, and Carrot Cake, they have also become the go-to online bakery for seasonal treats, snacks, and fruit baskets.

Bake Me A Wish Promises: On-Time Delivery and a Quality Gift

For our Bake Me A Wish gift review, we were sent a lovely holiday gift, the Solid Gold Bakery TowerSHOP NOW >>

Bake Me A Wish Gift Unboxing (Coupon & Reviews)

Our Solid Gold Bakery Tower arrived fresh and in great condition as promised.  This tower is $64 and includes:

  • 4-inch Cinnamon Coffee Cake
  • 10 Gourmet Cookies in Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Snickerdoodle, Butter Pecan, and Ginger Molasses
  • 8 Brownies in Chocolate Truffle, Chocolate Truffle w/Walnuts, Marble Cheesecake, and Cookies & Cream
  • 8 Gold Foil-Wrapped Hazelnut Chocolates or Chocolate Chip Cookies (depending on the temperature of the destination)
  • SHOP NOW >>

 

Bake Me A Wish takes care when packaging and shipping its’ gourmet bakery gifts, including birthday cakes, by using a number of components, like sturdy packaging, dry ice, and overnight delivery, to ensure a fast and secure trip to the final destination and that the items stay fresh in transit.  Shipping costs for this item are between $14.99 – $24.99 within the United States. SHOP NOW >>

chocolate truffles in gold foil spilling out of gift box-bake me a wish reviews-mealfinds

When your gift arrives, Bake Me A Wish recommends that you remove your gift from the cooler as soon as possible so that it can rest at room temperature for at least an hour before enjoying.

Birthday cakes and Gifts will stay fresh in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days, or in the freezer for up to 2 months.  Each gift includes Care Instructions on the label so that your gift recipient will know exactly how to store their gift to keep it fresh. SHOP NOW >>

personalized greeting card-bake me a wish reviews-mealfinds

Gift Personalization Options

You can select the Occasion, for example, Birthday, which changes the greeting card design.  Every birthday cake and gift comes with a greeting card that can be personalized with a message of up to 250 characters.

In addition, you can select a delivery date which is great if you like to plan ahead to ensure that your gift arrives on time.  Bake Me A Wish guarantees that your gift will be delivered on time via their shipping partner UPS or your shipping is free.

Bake Me A Wish even has a special selection of popular cake flavors that can include the name of your recipient on the gift or birthday cake!

SHOP NOW >>

brownies in package spilling out of gift box-bake me a wish reviews-mealfinds

So how did our treats taste?

We were excited to dig into our Solid Gold Bakery Tower and did a family tasting to get multiple opinions on the treats.

Our favorite was the coffee cake.  It was moist and tender on the inside with a crisp cinnamon and sugar crust on the outside.  If this little cake is any indication of how the larger cakes taste, I’m sure that they will be amazing.

Our second favorite treats were the brownies and the hazelnut chocolates.  The brownies, which come in four flavors were all rich and fudgy.  There was little difference between the four, one was plain, one had crunchy nuts, one had an oreo topping that added a creamy sweetness, and one was a marbled cheesecake with a little creaminess on top.

The hazelnut chocolates melted in your mouth good and everything you want from a little taste of chocolate.

Finally, our least favorite was the cookies.  Overall we found them to be on the sweet side and nothing special, though the Ginger Molasses stood out among the four flavors as the best and was tender and flavorful.  The oatmeal raisin, chocolate chip, and snickerdoodle were all a little too sweet and the butter pecan was both too sweet and tasted dry.

SHOP NOW >>

Overall

Bake Me A Wish birthday cakes and cupcakes are super fun and we could see sending one of these to friends or family that live far away.   We love that you can personalize some with the gift recipient’s name for a one-of-a-kind gift.  Bake Me A Wish makes birthday cake delivery easy and hassle-free.

In addition, the seasonal cakes and pies are the perfect gifts to send over the holidays when you can’t be there in person but want them to know that you are thinking about them.  If you are flying, you can send your treats directly to your destination so that you don’t come empty-handed to the holiday festivities!

SHOP NOW >>

Bake Me a Wish Reviews: Bottom Line

cookies in package spilling out of gift box-bake me a wish reviews-mealfinds

Bake Me A Wish delivers freshly baked gourmet bakery gifts including cakes for birthdays, holidays, and special occasions directly to your door with overnight nationwide delivery.

With delicious baked goods, customization options, personalized greeting cards, elegant packaging, and overnight delivery Bake Me A Wish has become the premier destination for birthday cakes, seasonal cakes and pies, gift baskets, and more.

We love the beautiful gift packaging as well as the personalized gift card.  Opening our gift tower was truly a magical adventure thanks to the thoughtful gold boxes, purple ribbon, and bakery-fresh treats.  We also love that you can select a delivery date ensuring that your gift arrives on time.

And while our treats tasted wonderful, we did notice that there are a limited number of specialty products made for specific dietary needs, and shipping fees can be pretty high especially for overnight delivery.

We recommend Bake Me A Wish cakes, birthday cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, and seasonal gifts to anyone looking to send a sweet treat in the mail, those looking for beautiful gift packaging with personalization options, and those looking for a unique food gift that will sure to please a crowd. SHOP NOW >>

Enjoy!

Looking for more desserts?  Check out our Dessert Directory >>

Looking for more gifts?  Check out our Curated Food Gift Ideas >>

Recent Posts

October 18, 2021

Shaker & Spoon Cocktail Kit Review

October 18, 2021

Best Adult Advent Calendar and Advent Calendar for Kids 2021

October 13, 2021

eat2explore Cooking Kit Reviews