Bake a Wish is a premium supplier of gourmet birthday and special occasion cakes.

Order gourmet cakes baked with the freshest ingredients from award-winning NYC bakeries.

Shop by cake type including cheesecake, cupcakes, brownies, and pies, or by occasion to find the perfect gift.

Unique flavors like lemon coconut, flourless chocolate, and rainbow cake are guaranteed to celebrate anyone’s birthday in the most special and personalized way.



Where to buy

Online: at Bake Me A Wish website

  • Meal Service Category Desserts , Snacks
  • Ships To Continental US
  • Dietary Options Gluten Free , Kosher
  • Starting Price Per Serving $3
  • Shipping / Delivery Fee $14.99
  • Serving Size Options 1, 2, 3, 4, 4+
  • Ave. Time To Table 0 in
  • Choices Available 100+
  • Selections Per Delivery Flexible
  • Family/Kid-Friendly Menu Options Yes
  • Add-Ons
  • Local or In-Store Pick Up No
  • Skip Delivery Available (subscription) No
  • Ease of Cancellation (subscription) N/A
  • Non-Subscription Option Yes
  • Gift Cards No

Bake Me A Wish Menu/Products

Bake Me A Wish

Chocolate Mousse Torte Cake

Mini Assorted Gourmet Cupcakes

Red Velvet Chocolate Cake

Tiramisu Classico Cake

Country Apple Pie

Bake Me A Wish Ratings


  • cost-effective

  • easy

  • eco-friendly

  • fast

  • fast delivery

  • flavor packed

  • great for families

  • great for singles

  • large portions