Tayst Coffee Reviews

Published on May 13, 2021
Last modified on June 20, 2023

For our Tayst Coffee reviews we were given a sample and this post contains affiliate links.  We may be compensated if you make a purchase.  All opinions are our own.

Written By Alison Chew    |    Dietitian Verified by Rebecca Housh, MS, RDN


What is Tayst Coffee?

Tayst Coffee delivers sustainably sourced and freshly roasted coffee in 100% compostable coffee pods for a convenient and guilt-free cup of coffee that tastes amazing and is better for the planet.


Tayst Coffee Coupon Code





Tayst Coffee Pros

  • 100% compostable coffee pods
  • Sustainably sourced coffee beans freshly brewed every month
  • Eco-friendly packaging
  • One-time purchase or Subscribe & Save 10%
  • $8 Trial Box: 20 compostable coffee pods + Free mug + Free shipping


Tayst Coffee Cons

  • Shipping is extra
  • Pods for Keurig only (Nespresso coming soon!)
  • Slightly more expensive than other options


Tayst Coffee Reviews: Trial Offer

Tayst Coffee has an amazing trial offer!

For just $8 you will receive 20 coffee pods, a free mug, and free shipping.  At the time of purchase, you will be enrolled in a monthly membership which is $29 plus shipping moving forward.  You can adjust your coffee or pause/cancel your plan at any time.

Limit – 1 Trial Box per household.


How much are Tayst coffee compostable coffee pods?


The cost of Tayst Coffee compostable pods varies depending on how many pods you order, if you order one-time or subscribe, and can be less than $0.67 per cup.

You can order Tayst Coffee compostable coffee pods a la carte or sign up for a flexible subscription and save 10%.  With a Tayst Coffee subscription, you choose how many coffee pods you want, type of brew, and your subscription will be delivered to your doorstep every month.

  • Trial Box: 20 compostable coffee pods + Free mug + Free shipping: One-time order $8
  • 30 compostable coffee pods: One-time order $24.44; Subscription $22
  • 50 compostable coffee pods: One-time order $38.89; Subscription $35
  • 80 compostable coffee pods: One-time order $61.12; Subscription $55
  • 100 compostable coffee pods: One-time order $74.44; Subscription $67
  • SHOP NOW >>




Where does Tayst Coffee ship?

Tayst Coffee ships to the United States and Canada.


How much is Tayst Coffee shipping?

Shipping costs vary depending on the size of your order and shipping destination. SHOP NOW >>


Tayst Coffee Reviews



Tayst Coffee has reimagined the convenient single-serve coffee pod by not only filling it with sustainably sourced coffee beans but by making it 100% compostable.  Unlike the plastic pods that are piling up in landfills all over the world, these pods give back nutrients to the soil as they decompose.

In addition to creating a better coffee pod for the planet, Tayst also wanted to create coffee that tastes great, is sustainably sourced, and supports farmers and the communities they live in.

Unlike other coffee pod brands, Tayst brews their coffee every month to ensure that you receive fresh-roasted coffee with every delivery.  They are also working with coffee farmers through the Rainforest Alliance, a non-profit that helps farmers improve their livelihoods, to grow and harvest the finest beans in South America free from agrochemicals.

Tayst currently offers 7 coffee blends including two full-bodied, dark blends, two medium-bodied blends, two flavored blends, Vintage Vanilla and Happy Hazelnut, and one decaf. SHOP NOW >>




For our Tayst Coffee reviews, we received the $25 Mixed Coffee Pods Gift.

This gift box includes 20 Cups of Mixed Coffees (10 Bold & Brazen dark blend and 10 Medium & Heroic medium blends), a Tayst Coffee Mug, along with a handwritten note all in eco-friendly packaging.  SHOP NOW >>


tayst coffee unboxing video-tayst coffee reviews-mealfinds


Like most coffee companies, Tayst offers both dark and medium-bodied blends.  The dark blend, as you would expect, is full-bodied, dark, and robust with rich bold flavors. Tayst has two dark blends, the Bold & Brilliant and the Bold & Brazen.

We tried the Bold & Brilliant and enjoyed this deep and complex brew with notes of earthy caramel and sweet black currants.  We didn’t get an acidic taste that can come with a dark roast and really liked the sweet flavor that came through, with a slight bitterness. SHOP NOW >>




Tayst also offers two medium-bodied blends including the Medium & Heroic and the Medium & Magnificant.  Tayst says their medium blends are smooth, deep, and mellow with earthy flavors shining through.

We tried the Medium & Heroic blend which is another bold blend, with slightly more acidity than the Bold & Brilliant, and a smooth finish.

We enjoyed drinking both coffee blends and didn’t have any trouble using these pods in our Keurig but did have to push down harder than usual to close the lid.  SHOP NOW >>


Tayst Coffee Reviews: Gifting



In addition to great-tasting sustainable coffee in compostable pods, Tayst also has several gifting options.  These gifts combine the Tayst coffee you love with fun coffee accessories like mugs, tumblers, and more all shipped in eco-friendly packaging with a handwritten gift note.

Gifts start at $25 and you can select your coffee blends and pods or ground coffee.

Everyone loves coffee and friends, family, and co-workers will love receiving this eco-friendly (and tasty) gift.  Corporate gifting is also available. SHOP NOW >>


Tayst Coffee Reviews: Bottom Line


Tayst Coffee truly delivers on its promise of sustainably sourced and freshly roasted great tasting coffee, 100% compostable coffee pods, and eco-friendly packaging.

We love the 100% compostable coffee pods and sustainably sourced coffee for a guilt-free cup of Joe every morning.  Both of the blends that we tried were very flavorful and the pods fit nicely into our Keurig.

And while we love this eco-friendly coffee, we didn’t see any pods for Nespresso machines and shipping is an additional fee.  The $8 trial offer with a free mug and free shipping is a great deal, but understand that you are signing up for a monthly subscription.  GET MY $8 TRIAL BOX >>

Compared to other compostable coffee pods that we have reviewed, the price of Tayst Coffee is in line with other brands with the added benefit of freshly brewed coffee and eco-friendly packaging.  We did, however, find compostable pods online that were less expensive, but without trying we can’t compare their taste, quality, or packaging.

We would recommend Tayst Coffee to any Keurig user who wants to cut back on single-use plastics while helping the planet, those who want sustainably sourced coffee in compostable pods with eco-friendly packaging any office that wants to do their part to help reduce the waste in our landfills.



Looking for more coffee or tea?  Check out our Coffee & Tea Directory >>

This post has been reviewed and approved by our dietitian Rebecca Housh, MS, RDN, LDN for nutritional accuracy.
rebecca-housh-ms-rdn-ldn-registered-dietitianRebecca Housh is a registered dietitian based in Chicago, IL. She earned a Bachelor of Science in Human Physiology from Boston University and a Master of Science in Human Nutrition from the University of Illinois in Chicago. Rebecca is passionate about the idea of food as medicine in both preventative and therapeutic care. Her current professional interests lie in food security, food access, and nutrition for chronic disease.

Recent Posts

June 23, 2023

Cold Brew Club Coffee Review

May 19, 2023

Thistle Meal Delivery Reviews

April 5, 2023

Georgie and Tom’s Reviews