This Misfits Market reviews post contains affiliate links and we were given a sample. If you make a purchase we may be compensated. All opinions are our own.
By Alison Chew
Misfits Market delivers organic produce and sustainably sourced pantry staples directly to your door at up to 40% less than grocery store prices. By rescuing organic produce that doesn’t look “perfect”, but is perfectly good to eat and still tastes delicious, they are breaking the cycle of food waste, saving millions of pounds of fresh food, and saving you money. Shop now >>
What We Like
Helping the earth, supporting organic farmers, and fighting food waste
Most products are less expensive than the grocery store (We saved $22!)
Fresh, organic produce and herbs
What We Don’t Like
Shipping is extra
Ordering process can be confusing
Items sell out quickly with different items every week
Misfits Market Reviews: Getting Started
We were really excited to try Misfits Market as we eat a lot of fresh produce in our house and are always looking for ways to save money and help the planet. And after learning about all of the food that is thrown away because it’s not “perfect”, and thinking about how many people in the world are starving, I can’t believe that we didn’t try them sooner.
Misfits Market is updating its site and shopping experience and we share both the current and new process in detail below. Shop now >>
Right now, to get started with Misfits Market you enter in your email and zip code and then select a box size. They are moving away from the 2 box sizes and will soon be offering customers the ability to spend a minimum amount per delivery.
For now, you:
Choose your base box: a Mischief box (small) or Madness box (large). Misfits Market says that “you can generally plan on a week’s worth of food for 1-2 people in our Mischief Box and a week’s worth of food for 3-5 people in our Madness Box.”
Select if you want your box delivered every week or every other week
Then choose your first delivery date
After you checkout, you will then be able to customize your box with organic produce and then add on things like discounted cooking staples and pantry items.
We were able to shop through the new Misfits Market experience that allows you to spend a minimum amount per delivery, $30, and select anything you want from their list of available organic produce and grocery items.
With this new experience, you sign up for Misfits and select your delivery date. You will then have a three-day window before your next billing and delivery date to pick your organic produce and add on groceries and pantry staples. If you reach the $30 box minimum in the 3-day window you are charged and they ship your box, if you don’t, that delivery is skipped and you are not charged.
This was a bit confusing as after I checked out I wanted to build my box but had to wait several days for my “window”. Shop now >>
During the 3-day “Build your box” window, items are first come first served, meaning that if you don’t log on when you receive the email you could miss out on some items that you wanted.
For example, we wanted organic strawberries because they were $3.99/lb and when we logged in they were already sold out. We pushed our delivery date out 2 days and then waited for the email to Build Our Box and jumped on as soon as we could.
As you can imagine, this is not ideal, but we do understand that Misfits doesn’t have unlimited quantities of every item in their marketplace. Compared to other similar services this is unique and something customers will need to get used to. Shop now >>
Misfits Market Reviews: Our Box
For our Misfits Market reviews, we selected a little bit of everything including organic fruit and vegetables, fresh herbs, along with grocery items, and even dog treats. The price of our Misfits Market box was $44.03 + $5.50 shipping. We love that with Misfits we can fully customize our box. Compared to similar services, you aren’t always able to select every item. Shop now >>
In our box we received
Organic Mixed Bell Peppers, 2: $2.99
Organic Yellow Onion, 1: $0.89
Organic Lemons, 3: $0.99
Organic Tommy Atkins Mango 1: $1.79
Organic Strawberries, 1 lb x 2 ($3.99 each): $7.98
Organic Valencia Oranges, 3: $1.49
Organic Green Beans, 12 oz: $2.29
Organic Blueberries, 6 oz: $2.99
Organic Bunched Broccoli, 2: $3.58
Fresh Organic Mint, 0.5 oz: $1.79
Organic Russet Potatoes, 2: $0.79
Organic Garlic Herb Cashews, 8 oz: $4.99
Organic Take & Bake Artisan Style Bread, 16 Oz: $3.49
Original 100% Grass-Fed Beef Stick, 0.5 oz (5 Ct): $3.99
Misfits Market recommends placing all temperature-sensitive items in the fridge as soon as possible as well as washing each item before eating them, as many are straight from the farm.
I didn’t know what to expect from this “rescued food” – would it simply have slight imperfections on the surface, come in an odd size, have out-of-date packaging? As we took our order out of the box, nothing stood out as super odd looking. I did notice that one of the green bell peppers and one of the lemons were a little bruised and the strawberries were very ripe. Shop now >>
Misfits Market Reviews: Organic Produce and Herbs
Misfits Market sources their produce from certified organic hand-picked farms and partners that supply non-GMO food across the Americas. They also include organic produce (e.g., citrus and avocados) sourced outside the country to offer more variety in your box. Much of their produce is seasonal, just like in your local grocery store. In the fall and winter, you can expect apples, potatoes, squash, sweet potatoes, and broccoli and in the spring and summer more berries, peaches, tomatoes, and asparagus.
We were surprised and delighted to see fresh organic herbs being offered as other services only offer organic fruit and vegetables. Shop now >>
Organic Fruit & Herbs
We received 3 Organic Lemons, 1 Organic Tommy Atkins Mango, 2 x 1lb Organic Strawberries, 3 Organic Valencia Oranges, 1x 6 oz container of Organic Blueberries, and 0.5 oz of Fresh Organic Mint.
The fruit selection went fast during the 3-day window and we recommend building your box as soon as you can. We loved seeing the fresh organic herbs, though there wasn’t a huge selection. When we saw the fresh mint we immediately added it to our box. It’s too early in the season for fresh mint in our garden and I love fresh mint iced tea with lemon on a warm spring or summer day.
All of the items were in good condition and didn’t look odd at all. There was one lemon that was a bit bruised and tasted fine. The strawberries were very ripe with one moldy strawberry in each of the two containers. Other than that, everything we received tasted wonderful. Shop now >>
Compared to similar organic fruit and herbs in our local grocery store, we saved $8.53 with Misfits Market. I will note that this is not a perfect comparison as we don’t have a food scale to weigh items and items are not exactly the same. Still, this can give you some idea of the savings. Shop now >>
Misfits Market Price
Grocery Store Price
Organic Lemons: 3
Organic Tommy Atkins Mango: 1
Organic Strawberries: 2 x 1lb
Organic Valencia Oranges: 3
Organic Blueberries: 6 oz
Fresh Organic Mint: 0.5 oz
We also received 2 Organic Green Bell Peppers, 1 Organic Yellow Onion, 12 oz of Organic Green Beans, 2 Organic Bunched Broccoli, and 2 Organic Russet Potatoes.
There was a good variety of organic vegetables available when we built our box and we easily found vegetables that we eat every week in stock, like potatoes, bell peppers, broccoli, onions, and green beans. We made a tofu and broccoli dinner, a tuna and green beans dinner, as well as a taco dinner with our organic vegetables. It was very convenient to have them delivered.
These items also arrived in good condition with just one bruised green pepper. The green peppers were on the small side, though. Shop now >>
Compared to similar organic vegetables in our local grocery store, we saved around an additional $4.79 with Misfits Market. As noted above, this is not an “apples to apples” (haha) comparison, but close. Shop now >>
Misfits Market Price
Grocery Store Price
Organic Green Bell Pepper: 2
Organic Yellow Onion: 1
Organic Green Beans: 12 oz
Organic Bunched Broccoli: 2
Organic Russet Potatoes: 2
So far we have saved a little over $13 on organic produce with Misfits Market over our local grocery store. Not bad! Shop now >>
All items arrived in perfect condition both inside and out. We checked the expiration dates and none were expired. Our dog Daisy loved her sweet potato chips, my son loved the mini beef sticks in his lunch, and I devoured the organic garlic herb cashews. We placed the take and bake bread in the freezer to use later.
Compared to similar organic and natural items in our local grocery store we saved around an additional $8.67 with Misfits Market. Shop now >>
Misfits Market Price
Grocery Store Price
Organic Garlic Herb Cashews, 8 oz
$6.39 (for similar)
Organic Take & Bake Artisan Style Bread, 16 Oz
$4.79 (for similar)
Original 100% Grass-Fed Beef Stick, 0.5 oz (5 Ct)
$6.45 ($1.29 each)
Sweet Potato Dog Treats, 5 oz
$7.50 (for similar)
This brings our total savings to $21.99 with Misfits Market compared to our local grocery store! That means that our $44 Misfits Market box would cost around $66 if we were to buy the same items at our local grocery store. That’s a 33% savings!Even when you factor in the shipping fee of $5.50, we still saved $16.50 or 25% over the grocery store and didn’t have to leave our house.
And while the savings are clearly there, you may have more variety in your local grocery store than on Misfits Market. So you could get some of the items you need/want each week and others may not be available. If you are flexible this might be ok, but if you are counting on an ingredient you may have to go to the grocery store so that you are guaranteed that you have it. Shop now >>
Misfits Market Reviews: Price, Shipping, and Delivery Areas
Misfits Market organic produce is up to 40% cheaper and their pantry staples are up to 50% cheaper than grocery store prices saving you money with every delivery. Because of their close relationship with farmers and makers they can secure these great prices and pass the savings on to you.
Misfits Market is a flexible subscription offering you the ability to skip deliveries, change delivery frequency, and cancel your subscription right in your Misfits account.
Currently, Misfits Market offers two box sizes: Mischief box (small) or Madness box (large). They say that “you can generally plan on a week’s worth of food for 1-2 people in our Mischief Box and a week’s worth of food for 3-5 people in our Madness Box.”
Misfits Market currently delivers to zip codes in Alabama, Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, Washington, D.C., West Virginia, and Wisconsin.
The cost of shipping is a flat rate of $5.50 to all locations in their delivery area and taxes vary by state. Your final order total is determined by your shipping address. Shop now >>
Misfits Market Reviews: Bottom Line
Misfits Market delivers organic fruit, vegetables, and herbs along with sustainably sourced pantry staples directly to your door. By rescuing organic produce that doesn’t look “perfect” they are breaking the cycle of food waste, saving millions of pounds of fresh food, and saving you money.
We love that when we shop through Misfits we are helping the Earth, supporting organic farmers, and fighting food waste. We also love that we can save money, up to 40%, over grocery store prices. Let’s face it, organic produce is expensive, but the health benefits are numerous. Misfits allow you to eat organic fruits and vegetables at a fraction of the cost. We were able to save $22, around 33%, by shopping with Misfits.
When comparing Misfits to other organic produce delivery services, we like that you can fully customize your order and won’t end up with food that you don’t care for. We also like that you can add pantry and grocery items to your box with additional savings and added convenience.
And while the savings are clearly there, the variety might not the same as what you would find in the organic section of your local grocery store, and items tend to sell out fast. In addition, as Misfits changes over from offering 2 box sizes to a $30 minimum order, the ordering process can be a bit confusing with the 3-day “build your box” window and something to get used to.
We recommend Misfits Market for anyone who is looking to support organic farmers, fight food waste, and save on organic produce and grocery items. Shop now >>