Carnivore Club Reviews

Published on November 23, 2020
Last modified on June 18, 2021

This Carnivore Club Reviews post contains affiliate links, we were given a sample, and we may be compensated if you make a purchase.  All opinions are our own.


By Alison Chew

Reviewed by Rebecca Housh, MS, RDN

Carnivore Club

Carnivore Club delivers premium cured meat created with passion and craftsmanship by artisans from around the world directly to your door.  Choose from a monthly subscription and be delighted with a new, unique selection of extraordinary cured meats every month, or shop their Marketplace for a one-time purchase for yourself or give as a gift to the meat-lovers in your life.

Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>

What We Like

  • Subscription and a la carte options
  • Unique, premium cured meats from small artisans
  • Great gift idea!

What We Don’t Like

  • Can’t reorder favorites from a monthly box on the Carnivore Club website
  • Shipping is not included

Carnivore Club Reviews

For our Carnivore Club reviews, we received a sample of the Snack and Classic monthly subscription boxes. Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>

Carnivore Club Unboxing by MealFinds


Carnivore Club Reviews: Snack Box


Our Snack Box included 5x 1oz meat sticks from Mythical Meats and 3x 2.5 oz bags of jerky from People’s Choice Beef Jerky.

The People’s Choice Beef Jerky included Nashville Hot Beef Jerky, Carne Seca Limon Con Chile Beef Jerky, and Garlic Ginger Beef Jerky.  People’s Choice Beef Jerky, located in Los Angeles, CA, is a family-owned business that has been making handcrafted beef jerky since 1929. Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>


  • Nashville Hot:  Spicy!  Cayenne pepper packs the smokey heat in this jerky.  This jerky was a little too spicy for me, but my husband loved it.
  • Carne Seca Limon Con Chile: The red pepper and black pepper bring some heat, with the guajillo chili powder providing deep rich flavor with a touch of lemon.  We all enjoyed this jerky!  Not too spicy, but packed with flavor.
  • Garlic Ginger:  Our favorite!  Savory and sweet with a garlic taste and a ginger zing.


    Next up, we tried the exotic meat jerky from Mythical Meats.  Mythical Meats combines their passion for jerky with their love for magical creatures.  They have reimagined exotic game meats as some of the most beloved mythical creatures to bring you super fun, and tasty, meat sticks. Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>


    • Griffin: Ostrich
    • Basilisk: Alligator Mild w/ Beef
    • Chupacabra: Chorizo Mexican Style
    • Loch Ness Monster: Beef & Mild Buffalo
    • Werewolf: Venison Teriyaki



    My son was really excited to try these meat sticks both because of the fun names, like Werewolf, and because of the exotic meat like Ostrich and Alligator and they did not disappoint!

    My husband, son, and I had an exotic jerky tasting one afternoon.  My son’s favorite was the Werewolf/Venison Teriyaki with a slightly sweet flavor and no gamey taste at all.  The Chupacabra had a nice spicy kick and definitely tasted like Mexican style chorizo.  I really liked the Basilisk/Alligator as well as the Griffin/Ostrich. Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>


    We enjoyed the unique snack assortment in this box and the fact that it came with both bagged jerky and meat sticks (both perfect for snacking or taking with you on-the-go!).   When we added up the cost for the products included in our box from pricing on The People’s Choice and Mythical Meats sites, the cost would be around $30.50 ($18 for the jerky and $12.50 for the meat sticks) before tax or shipping. The cost of a Carnivore Club Snack Box is $24.99 + shipping and is a great value for the items that we received. Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>

    Carnivore Club

    Carnivore Club Reviews: Classic Box


    Our Classic Box included 5 items from Soupie Brothers.  Soupie Brothers, from Mount Carmel, PA, deliver delicious Italian style, dry-cured meats to your door.  Their Soupie recipe for cured meat dates back to when Italian immigrants came to the United States to work in the coal mines and were originally created as a portable snack with a long shelf life for those working in the mines. This recipe and tradition made its way to the Pennsylvania coal region and the Soupie Brothers are excited to share it. Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>

    carnivore-club-soupie-bros2 carnivore-club-soupie-bros4

    • Original Soupie Sausage: Authentic Italian dry-cured meat is made with ham, tenderloin, and pork butts
    • Chorizo Salami:  A Spanish classic with hints of fresh paprika and a rich smokiness
    • Smoked Soupie Sticks: Like the Original Soupie, but in an on-the-go snack stick
    • Beef Landjaeger Sticks: German-style beef stick made through a long smoking session with a natural smoke flavor
    • Spicy Salametti: Cold smoked salami with mild heat and a smokey flavor



    We decided to have a Soupie cured meat tasting, pairing the meat with vodka martini’s, cheese, and grapes. Yum!  Overall, this meat was delicious with a rich flavor throughout.  The Soupie sticks and Original Soupie were wonderful and are perfect on a salad, paired with cheese for lunch, or as a snack on the go.  The Chorizo packs some spice as does the Spicy Salametti, which my husband loved.  I really enjoyed the Smoked Soupie sticks for their rich smokey taste as well as the Beef Landjager for the same reason.

    When we added up the cost for the products included in our box from pricing on the Soupie Brothers site, the cost would be around $41 before tax or shipping. The cost of a Classic Carnivore Club Box is $39.99 + shipping and is in line with the value that you receive. Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>


    The Classic box makes for a wonderful gift and is also perfect for enjoying with a nice cheese board, red wine, and good friends. To have new, exclusive, premium cured meats delivered every month would certainly be a treat for any meat-lover.

    We love to support small businesses and think that a Carnivore Club allows us to do just that while experiencing new and interesting meat each month.  And while we really enjoyed both of the Carnivore Club boxes, I would like to be able to reorder our favorites on the Carnivore Club website instead of tracking them down online. Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>

    Carnivore Club Reviews: Subscription


    With the Carnivore Club subscription, you have two options, the Snack Box and the Classic Box.

    The Snack Box is filled with premium cured snacking meats, like jerky and meat sticks, from the Carnivore Club’s favorite artisans.


    The Classic Box contains 4-6 premium cured meats, like salami, prosciutto and pepperoni, from top artisans giving you a unique meat experience in every box.


    Signing up is easy-  Select your box, choose your delivery frequency, receive your box and enjoy!

    Carnivore Club Reviews: Marketplace

    If you are not ready to sign up for a subscription box just yet and want to enjoy premium cured meats take a look at the Carnivore Club Marketplace.  Here you can order a la carte.  Some of the items that caught our eye are the Wild Game Meats Sampler and the Mega Meat Bundle.

    Wild Game Meats Sampler ($64.99)


    • This sampler includes 12 wild game meat items in various sizes as well as a 20L Dry Bag.  Have you ever tasted a Jackalope?  Here’s your chance!

    Mega Meat Bundle ($69.99)

    Carnivore Club Mega Meat Bundle Unboxing by MealFinds


    • Packed with 18 delicious meat items including 8 x Meat Sticks like Pepperettes or Pepperoni Sticks, 8 x Jerky, and 2 x Whole or Sliced Salamis.


    Both would make great gifts!

    Carnivore Club Reviews: Gifting


    Carnivore Club has several gifting options.  You can gift a snack or classic box, give a subscription gift card, or give a gift from the Marketplace.

    Some of our favorite Marketplace gifts include:

    Exotic Jerky Bouquet ($44.99)


    • Featured in our Food Gifts Galore gift guide
    • Includes 20 long stem jerky sticks (5 of each – Elk Sticks, Buffalo Sticks, Venison (Mild) Sticks, and Venison (Hot) Sticks)

    The Jerky Gift Tin ($69.99 )


    • Features 10 packs of unique premium jerky


    Carnivore Club Reviews: Bottom Line


    Carnivore Club lives up to its promise of delivering exclusive, unique, premium cured meats to your door.  We love that they support small artisan businesses and that you can discover new products every month with a subscription.  We only wish that we can reorder our favorites through the Carnivore Club website.

    Carnivore Club also makes for a wonderful gift!  Give a subscription, a gift card, or a gift from the Marketplace and we know that the meat-lover in your life will appreciate your thoughtfulness with every bite of their tasty meat gift. Take 10% OFF Your First Subscription Box with code CHEW10 >>


    Looking for more snacks?  Check out our Snack Directory >>

    Carnivore Club

    This post has been reviewed and approved by our dietitian Rebecca Housh, MS, RDN, LDN for nutritional accuracy.
    rebecca-housh-ms-rdn-ldn-registered-dietitianRebecca Housh is a registered dietitian based in Chicago, IL. She earned a Bachelor of Science in Human Physiology from Boston University and a Master of Science in Human Nutrition from the University of Illinois in Chicago. Rebecca is passionate about the idea of food as medicine in both preventative and therapeutic care. Her current professional interests lie in food security, food access, and nutrition for chronic disease.


    Recent Posts

    July 22, 2021

    RAWgust 30 Day Challenge

    July 20, 2021

    ModifyHealth Food Delivery Reviews

    July 7, 2021

    Blue Apron Meals Review